Setting Boundaries VS. Building Walls: Why Protecting Your Peace Doesn’t Mean Shutting People Out
- Your Story Counselling
- Jan 12
- 6 min read
Boundaries have become one of the most talked-about concepts in self-help culture—but also one of the most misunderstood. Many people worry that setting boundaries will make them seem “mean,” “difficult,” or “cold.” Others swing to the opposite extreme and begin building emotional walls, cutting themselves off from people in the name of self-protection.
So how do you know whether you’re setting healthy boundaries… or building emotionally protective walls?
This article explores the difference, why so many people (especially people-pleasers) confuse the two, and how therapy can help you build boundaries that create healthier, safer relationships.
Boundaries vs. Walls: Why They Often Get Confused
Both boundaries and walls come from a desire to feel safe.But they lead to very different outcomes.
Boundaries protect connection.
They tell others:
“This is how you can be close to me in a way that feels safe and respectful.”
Walls block connection.
They tell others:
“I’m keeping you out so you can’t hurt me.”
Both responses are understandable—especially if you’ve been hurt, ignored, or overwhelmed in the past. But knowing the difference helps you build relationships rooted in clarity, trust, and emotional well-being.
What Healthy Boundaries Look Like
Healthy boundaries are intentional, flexible, and grounded in self-awareness.
They sound like:
“I can help, but I need 24 hours notice.”
“I’m not available for that tone.”
“I can’t talk about this right now, let’s revisit later.”
“I need space tonight, but I care about you.”
Healthy boundaries:
Clarify what you can offer
Respect your needs and limits
Allow closeness without sacrificing yourself
Communicate expectations clearly
Support mutual respect in relationships
Boundaries are a form of connection with clarity.
What Emotional Walls Look Like
Walls are an understandable response to hurt—but they often become overprotective.
Walls sound like:
“I don’t need anyone.”
“I’m done. I’m never doing this again.”
“I don’t want to talk about it—ever.”
“People always let you down.”
Walls:
Shut down vulnerability
Prevent emotional closeness
Come from fear or past wounds
Keep you “safe” but lonely
Make relationships feel distant or brittle
Walls come from protection through disconnection. They are a survival strategy—but not a long-term solution.
Why People-Pleasers Struggle With Boundaries (and Often Build Walls Instead)
If you grew up with:
criticism
conflict avoidance
inconsistent parenting
emotional neglect
cultural expectations to “be good”
pressure to keep the peace
…then you likely learned that your needs were inconvenient, unsafe, or not allowed.
So when you try to set boundaries as an adult, it often feels:
rude
selfish
wrong
dangerous
This makes people-pleasers more likely to avoid conflict until they hit their emotional limit—and then suddenly snap, cut someone off, or build a wall instead of a boundary.
It’s not your fault.It’s a learned survival response.
How to Know Whether You're Setting a Boundary or Building a Wall
Here’s a quick guide:
1. Motivation
Boundary: “I want to protect my peace and stay connected.”
Wall: “I want to avoid being hurt again at all costs.”
2. Communication
Boundary: spoken clearly and calmly.
Wall: silent withdrawal, avoidance, or shutdown.
3. Flexibility
Boundary: can adjust over time.
Wall: rigid, all-or-nothing.
4. Impact on Relationships
Boundary: leads to healthier connection.
Wall: leads to distance or disconnection.
5. Emotional Root
Boundary: grounded in self-awareness.
Wall: grounded in fear, resentment, or past hurt.
When Walls Are Understandable (and Sometimes Necessary)
Before anyone feels shame about having walls, its essential to know that walls are not only understandable but sometimes very necessary.
Walls can be protective and sometimes appropriate when:
A relationship is unsafe
A person is emotionally abusive
A caregiver or partner has repeatedly ignored your boundaries
You're actively healing from trauma
You’re not ready for connection yet
You are allowed to protect yourself. Safety always comes before connection.
Walls become a concern only when they block the relationships you actually want to have.
How to Start Practicing Healthy Boundaries Instead of Walls
1. Start Small
Choose one low-stakes boundary to practice, like:
“I’ll respond tomorrow.”
“I can stay for one hour.”
Small wins build confidence.
2. Use “I” Statements
Boundaries work best when they focus on your action:
“I will step away if the conversation gets heated.”
“I can only take calls before 9 pm.”
You’re not controlling others—you’re stating your limits.
3. Tolerate the Discomfort
Setting boundaries will feel awkward—especially if you’ve always prioritized others. Discomfort is not danger. It’s a sign you’re growing.
4. Repair Instead of Retreating
If you shut down or build a wall, you can repair by saying:
“I reacted from a place of overwhelm. Here’s what I actually need.”
Repair is connection-building.
5. Seek Support When It Feels Hard
If boundaries feel impossible, dangerous, or confusing—therapy helps you understand why and how to strengthen them safely.
How Therapy Helps You Shift From Walls to Boundaries
Therapy gives you a safe space to:
unpack your fears around conflict
understand childhood or cultural conditioning
process emotional hurts that created your walls
practice saying what you need
build healthier relationship patterns
reclaim your voice without feeling selfish
learn boundaries that support connection—not disconnection
Boundaries are a skill. Walls are a symptom. Therapy helps you build one and heal the other.
If You Struggle With Boundaries, You’re Not Alone
Many people—especially people-pleasers, BIPOC adults, caregivers, and those healing from trauma—confuse boundaries with walls.But learning the difference can transform your relationships, your confidence, and your emotional well-being.
You deserve relationships where you feel safe, respected, and connected.And that starts with boundaries that honour you.
Interested in Support? We’re Here for You.
Your Story Counselling supports individuals who struggle with people-pleasing patterns, emotional boundaries, burnout, and relationship stress. Our therapists can help you build boundaries rooted in self-respect—not fear.
📍 Therapy in Markham, Vaughan, and across Ontario (Virtual Options Available)💛 Individual, Couples, and Family Therapy
🌿 Continue Your Healing Journey
If this article resonated with you, you don’t have to navigate these feelings alone. Explore ways to connect, learn, and take your next step toward support:
Take the first step toward clarity, healing, and growth — we’re here to listen.
Get to know our compassionate team of therapists offering care in multiple languages and approaches.
We believe therapy should be accessible. Explore our transparent pricing and options.
Affordable, supervised therapy sessions available through our therapist-in-training program.
Your Story Counselling Services is a multicultural, inclusive, BIPOC clinic that offers online services as well as in-person sessions in Vaughan and Markham.
Judy Lui and her team of clinicians and supervised therapist interns offer trauma-informed, clinical counselling in the form of art, play, and talk therapy. With an emphasis on social equity and justice,
Your Story offers counselling at a range of fee levels. Judy continues to see her clients, manages the clinic as Clinical Director, and mentors master ’s-level therapist interns.
Judy has been featured in the Toronto Star, where she discussed the impact of mental health struggles and the toll of COVID-19 on romantic relationships. She also co-authored a chapter in the first edition of An Intersectional Approach to Sex Therapy Centering the Lives of Indigenous, Racialized, and People of Color. She is a committee member with the Anti-Racism Advocacy Group at the Canadian Counselling and Psychotherapy Association, where she helps organize community events and panels on racial trauma and advocacy.
Judy is also one of three 2024 RBC Canadian Women Entrepreneur Awards Micro-Business Finalists and will represent the Central Canadian Region (Ontario & Montreal) for this honour.
Affordable Therapy York Region is committed to making quality mental health care more accessible across Markham, Vaughan, Concord, and the greater York Region. We offer both virtual and in-person sessions through a diverse team of supervised therapist interns and registered clinicians, with services starting as low as $20 per session.
Our clinic prioritizes culturally responsive, trauma-informed, and inclusive care, ensuring that therapy is respectful of your identity, background, and lived experience. Whether you're seeking support for anxiety, relationships, grief, or personal growth, we offer therapy that meets you where you are — emotionally and financially.
We also offer a free 15-minute consultation to help you find the right therapist fit before you commit.Learn more or get started today at www.affordabletherapyyorkregion.ca.
If you have additional questions regarding the contents of this article please feel free to contact us and we will be happy to answer you.
Should you have questions or inquiries regarding counselling and the process of counselling, please visit our FAQ page. contact us to ask questions, or learn more about our team of therapists before signing up for a free 15 minute consultation.
Terms and Conditions of Use:
The information provided in this article is intended to be general knowledge and does not constitute as professional advice or treatment. This information is not intended for the use of diagnosis or treatment. Please do not share or distribute this article without the proper referencing or written/verbal consent of Judy Lui. Additional information can be found at www.yourstorycounselling.com or requested via info@yourstorycounselling.com
Meta Description (SEO-Optimized)
Learn the difference between healthy boundaries and emotional walls. Understand why people-pleasers struggle with setting limits, how past experiences shape boundary issues, and how therapy can help create healthier relationships rooted in clarity and connection.
Focus Keywords
healthy boundaries
emotional walls
therapy for people pleasers
relationship patterns
boundaries vs walls
people pleaser burnout
emotional safety
communication in relationships
healing attachment wounds
